Pasqualin draws a sharp contrast between the Carlist commemoration and the Italian Republic’s Day of National Unity and the Armed Forces. While the republic celebrates the military victory of 1918 and the ideal of national unity, Carlists reaffirm their fidelity to the legitimate monarchy. For Pasqualin, these observances represent two opposing worldviews, “one founded upon usurpation, the other upon fidelity.” His argument challenges the notion that political legitimacy can be established through popular approval, military victory, or the mere possession of power.
Especially compelling is his insistence that “the true conflict is not between one set of borders and another, nor does it concern the fetish of nations and nationalisms.” Rather, “the struggle is, and will remain, between legitimacy and usurpation.” It is a distinction too often lost on those who mistake traditionalism for nationalism.
The article finds its most powerful expression in the declaration, “We celebrate fidelity.” As Pasqualin reminds us, “legitimacy is neither acquired through a plebiscite nor lost through defeat.” These words affirm a principle that transcends the fortunes of any particular dynasty or political regime.
Having discovered this meaningful tradition, I shall join the Carlists in spirit this November 4, honoring the legitimate monarchy and remembering the struggle against usurpation.
Viva Cristo Re! Viva la Monarchia Legittima!
~ By Giovanni di Napoli, November 3rd, Feasts of Sant’Uberto di Liegi and St. Winfred
