Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Thoughts on the She Built NYC Monument Debacle. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Thoughts on the She Built NYC Monument Debacle. Sort by date Show all posts

September 13, 2019

Some Thoughts on the She Built NYC Monument Debacle

Monument outside St. Francis Cabrini
Church in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn
I wasn’t planning on writing about the recent St. Frances Xavier Cabrini monument controversy in New York City, but several readers convinced me to break my silence and vent my presumed “outrage.” Yielding to their appeals I will offer my two cents, though I’m sure my opinion on the debacle will not be what they imagined it to be.

For those who are unaware, a competition was held in 2018 by the She Built NYC project to recognize seven so-called “trailblazing women of New York” for a monument-building initiative to help address the lack of statues depicting women in the city and “correct” the historical record.

The progressive scheme was spearheaded by Deputy Mayor Alicia Glen and Chirlane McCray, wife of New York’s socialist Mayor Bill De Blasio. How Mrs. McCray and gang acquired the expertise or authority to spend an estimated $5 million in taxpayer money to build these monuments in a crumbling city, is puzzling to say the least, but their poor execution of the project was most definitely not a surprise.

Predictably, the project was received with as much enthusiasm as the mayoral elections.(1) With an estimated population of 8.6 million people, a mere 1,800 suggestions were made. Of the 320 women nominated, Mother Cabrini was by far the most popular, receiving 219 votes. Despite her popularity among voters, the first American Saint was snubbed by McCray and her blue-ribbon panel. Instead, they chose their own nominees, two of which aren’t even women.(2)

Honestly, who really expected otherwise from this administration? Like virtually all politicians, New York’s First Family have their own agenda and will stop at nothing to impose their will on the rest of us.


Stained glass window at the St. Frances
Cabrini Shrine in Washington Heights, NY
Photos by New York Scugnizzo
Needles to say I did not vote. Having never expected good or fair results from them to begin with, I can truthfully say I’m not upset or disappointed at all. In fact, I’m actually a little relieved they chose to ignore the “will of the people.” Not because the decision exposes their partisan hypocrisy and shows the true face of our Democratic betters. No, that mask has been off for a long time and we already know the whole democratic process is a sham. I’m relieved because our beloved patroness will not be lumped in with some of the other less than admirable honorees or tainted with any connection to this amoral administration.

I’m also glad we won’t have to deal with a potentially heinous work of art by some two-bit hack impersonating an artist. We Catholics have enough problems with modernists in our Church corrupting the aesthetics of our faith (among other things) from within that we don’t need secular and other hostile forces piling on the hate and degradation. Besides, we already have monuments and shrines dedicated to this great Saint. Her likeness can be found in many churches across the city, most notably at St. Francis Cabrini Church in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn and the St. Frances Xavier Cabrini Shrine in Washington Heights, New York.

As an aside, I would like to add that unlike some of my aggrieved paesani, I do not believe the saint was snubbed because she was Italian. To be sure, I’m not denying the existence of anti-Italian bigotry; I experience it often enough myself to know that it's alive and well, but if anything, the Mayor and his wife seem to be Italophiles in their own fashion. I believe Mother Cabrini is not getting a statue because she was a good Catholic, which stands diametrically opposed to the values they’re trying to promote with this contrived agitprop.

Sure, I would like to see more monuments to our saints and heroes in our city, but in an increasingly secular, iconoclastic society bent on rewriting history and tearing down statues of historical figures deemed controversial by the PC apparatchiki, the likelihood of that becomes ever more improbable. Instead, our community needs to start focusing more on upholding traditional values and the formation of faith and character. We need to prevent the closing of our churches and the dissolution of our families, or, like with so many today, these monuments will cease to retain their meaning. 

                                     ~ Giovanni di Napoli, Thursday, September 12th, Feast of the Most Holy Name of Mary 
The good, the bad, and the ugly: Notable statues in New York City
depicting women include Lady Liberty by Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi on Liberty
Island; Fearless Girl by Kristen Visbal outside the New York Stock Exchange;
and Eyes by Louise Bourgeois in the otherwise beautiful Wagner Park
(1) In 2017 the incumbent Mayor Bill de Blasio won re-election with only 726,361 votes. A measly 8.5% of the city’s voters participated in the democratic charade. This was a drop from the already beggarly 795,679 votes he got in 2013.

(2) Shirley Chisholm came in 3rd with 91 votes; Katherine Walker came in 5th with 68 votes; Marsha P. Johnson came in 7th with 65 votes; Sylvia Rivera came in 19th with 21 votes; Elizabeth Jennings Graham came in 22nd with 17 votes; Billie Holiday came in 24th with 16 votes; and Dr. Helen Rodriguez Trías came in 42nd with a paltry 7 votes.

October 29, 2020

Reflections on NYC's Mother Cabrini Monument

Mother Cabrini statue by Jill and Giancarlo Biagi at Battery Park City Esplanade
Thanks to the ongoing lawlessness and comrade de Blasio’s inane policies (to put it mildly), I’ve been avoiding the city as much as possible. Not since Dinkins have I felt this unsafe riding the subway or walking the muraled streets of Manhattan. Nevertheless, risking a visit last Sunday for the 119th Annual Feast of San Vincenzo Martire in Little Italy, I decided to make the most of it and finally go see the new St. Frances Xavier Cabrini Memorial in Battery Park City.
Unveiled on October 12th by Governor Andrew Cuomo for Columbus Day, the bronze statue depicts Mother Cabrini on a large paper boat with two young Italian American orphans and/or immigrants. In full view of the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island, the well kempt and squatter free location is befitting the patron saint of immigrants. Ideally it should have been erected in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, so the good people of Sacred Hearts and St. Stephen’s Parish who overwhelmingly voted for her could enjoy it in relative safety, but I digress.

While the monument is better than I expected (see my Thoughts on the She Built NYC Monument Debacle), I’m sorry to say I’m not a big fan. As far as contemporary art goes, it’s fine; it just doesn't suit my taste. That said, I have plenty of friends who disagree and absolutely love it. At least I think we can all agree that it's better than the heinous “Medusa with the Head of Perseus” monstrosity that was installed the following day outside New York County Criminal Court in Lower Manhattan.

Quite frankly, my real problem with the monument is not artistic or the location, it's the association with Cuomo. Sure, it was his brainchild, but the Governor’s stance on abortion alone should have precluded him from having anything to do with this project. Yes we are all sinners, but abortion is irreconcilable with Catholicism; and to me, there is something perverse about having this hypocrite’s name engraved on a statue of a Catholic Saint.
Also, the project wasn’t done in good faith. Far from any true devotion to Mother Cabrini (the bad blood between the Governor and Mayor is well documented), it was clearly green lighted to score some cheap political points and to spite Mayor de Blasio, whose wife Chirlane McCray failed to uphold the results of her own statue contest and snubbed the undisputed winner to suit her own biased political agenda.
Mother Cabrini is absolutely deserving of any and all recognition for her saintly life and I would love to see more monuments dedicated to her and other Catholic heroes. However, right now this city is dying and every single penny should be spent on policing and rebuilding New York City’s crumbling infrastructure. Stop squandering resources on noxious social projects, ridiculous street murals, and unnecessary monuments in these shameless self-promoting vanity projects. Our beloved patroness would be appalled by the insufferable misuse of funding and the godlessness of the corrupt buffoons in charge.

~ Giovanni di Napoli, October 28th, Feast of Saints Simon and Jude