November 17, 2026

Ancestry Sheds Some Light on My 23andMe

Limestone capital with four heads emerging from acanthus leaves,
Apulia, probably Troia, carved about 1230 by Apulian sculptors
working for the court of Frederick II Hohenstaufen (1194-1250)
Around this time last year, I wrote about my experience with 23andMe (see The Neanderthal in 23andMe) and how the results left me with more questions than answers. Hoping to resolve some of those mysteries, I turned to Ancestry.com, which, thankfully, offered a somewhat clearer picture of my genetic heritage.

Unlike its competitor, Ancestry provided a straightforward breakdown of my ancestral origins into four regions: Southern Italy (92%), Sicily (4%), Albania (3%), and the Southwestern Balkans (1%). Gone were the more ambiguous classifications such as Caucasian, Mesopotamian, and Anatolian that had puzzled me before. Their absence is consistent with my suspicion that these distant genetic affinities reflect ancient migrations that helped shape the indigenous populations of Southern Italy, rather than necessarily indicating more recent Near Eastern ancestors.

The Albanian and Balkan components came as no surprise. As I mentioned previously, my family has Arbëreshë roots in San Costantino Albanese, a historic Albanian settlement in Lucania. What did surprise me was the relatively small Sicilian percentage. With two great-grandparents hailing from Adrano and Gaggi, I expected a considerably higher figure. Apparently, the genetic distinction between Sicilians and their mainland cousins is not always as pronounced as regional pride might suggest.

Another curiosity was the complete absence of any identifiable Norman, Germanic, or French ancestry. Being relatively fair myself, and with blond hair and blue eyes somewhat common throughout my extended family, I half expected some genetic evidence of those northern interlopers who once ruled parts of the Mezzogiorno. Perhaps their contributions, if any, have simply been absorbed into the broader Southern Italian genetic profile.

Of course, these tests offer estimates of genetic similarity to modern reference populations, not a definitive accounting of every people who contributed to our ancestry. Still, after two tests, I seem to have confirmed what I already knew: I am overwhelmingly Southern Italian, with a little Albanian thrown in for good measure. At least my Neanderthal credentials remain undisputed.

~ By Giovanni di Napoli, November 16th, Feasts of San Giuseppe Moscati and Santa Geltrude la Grande